That is a bit of a misquote, Dave. You cut out the part where I said, "... the rest of the party...". Here is the full quote:dmw71 wrote:Objectively speaking, I think Grimnail played his character perfectly. Let's not forget, a barbarian is not about to do a magic-user any favors (like suppressing its natural instinct to attack).Alethan wrote:...and has seen the caster use AOE spells to great effect.
Sorry if it wasn't clear that I was excluding him from the bit about Garth's spell casting abilities... By "we", I meant the rest of us who were going at the trogs.Alethan wrote: While it is true Grim would know nothing of the others' battle tactics, the rest of the party has been in two significant large fights up to this point (three, if you count the first part of this trog battle) and has seen the caster use AOE spells to great effect. We should have worked together better, relying on him to reduce the number of trogs we had to face all at once. That is character knowledge, not meta-gaming.
I think people do barbarians a disservice by assuming they have a base level of intelligence and are completely instinctual. Even the trogs know to lead a fight with ranged weapons before you engage in melee.