Sorry for the delay, Grog. Currently I need to be more precise and accurate in this game than in the other ones I'm GMing. The distances you stated are correct. Paladin can see the men in the center (Robber 1) and on the right (2) And they have line of sight (LOS) o him.
There's no LOS between him and the stationary one (3) to the left. The curvature of the roof and the skylight blocks it. It's the same for the galloping one to the left (4).
My previous post about (4) was a mistake. Paladin couldn't see him galloping, or at this range hear the galloping. But he could hear the boy's yells.
The robbers rolled a 1 for initiative. Paladin initiative roll is up.
There's no LOS between him and the stationary one (3) to the left. The curvature of the roof and the skylight blocks it. It's the same for the galloping one to the left (4).
My previous post about (4) was a mistake. Paladin couldn't see him galloping, or at this range hear the galloping. But he could hear the boy's yells.
The robbers rolled a 1 for initiative. Paladin initiative roll is up.